Bethany Dark Wash A-line Long Denim Skirt

I own two of the Bethany skirts in a dark wash and a lighter wash. Both fit great and feel even better. I ordered this skirt as the Bethany is one of my favorite skirts that Inherit sells but unfortunately the fit is off. It's not a-line like my other washes in the same skirt, but more of a mermaid cut with the hip area tighter and the skirt flaring out at the knee. At first, I thought it was the size as I had ordered a size 6 after referring to the measurements, but it was tighter in the hips than expected and looser in the waist. I purchased the next size up, which was a size 8, hoping that would fix the problem, but instead it made the waist even looser leaving a gap between my back and the back of the skirt while making the hips not as tight. Unfortunately I returned both. Also, the wash isn't much different than the previous dark wash in that the lighter spots on the front and back are just a slightly darker shade of dark compared to the previous dark wash. So you're basically getting the dark wash in the same wash but with a slightly darker light spot on both the front and back. I love my Bethanys but this 'new' Bethany isn't the same as my previous two which is disappointing.